Photo Caption & Contact Email

Banner Photograph: Members of the North Nova Scotia Highlanders in England, 1941 (courtesy of Robert MacLellan, Cape Breton Military History Collections)

Contact E-mail Address: brucefrancismacdonald@gmail.com

Friday 27 September 2024

Rifleman Garfield James Munroe—Killed in Action September 27, 1944

Garfield James Munroe was born in Little Dover, Guysborough County, on September 12, 1920. Garfield’s father, Daniel Munroe, was the son of Daniel Munroe Sr. and Elizabeth Horne, Dover. His mother, Annie Laura Harnish, was the daughter of James Harnish and Jane Horne, Sober Island, Halifax County.

Rifleman Garfield James Munroe's headstone, Calais Canadian Military Cemetery

Daniel and Annie were married in Dover on February 12, 1918. Before year’s end, their first child, Alonzo Vincent, was born. Garfield, the couple’s second child, arrived two years later. By the time of the 1931 Canadian census, five more children had joined the family—Mary Ada (YOB c. 1923); Lauchlin Daniel (YOB c. 1925); Marie Jane (YOB c. 1927); Kenneth Norman (YOB c. 1929); and Thomas Milton (YOB c. 1931).

Four more children—Ernest Eugene (YOB c. 1933); Valerie Ann (YOB c. 1935); Lawrence Francis (YOB c. 1939) and Franklin Patrick (YOB c. 1942)—were born after 1931. Two other children died in infancy or at birth during that time—Edward Lloyd died July 28, 1935, at age eight months, while “Baby Munroe” (no gender identified) died at birth on February 10, 1938.

Garfield Munroe attended public school for nine years. After completing Grade VII, he entered the work force at age 16. For five years, he worked in the local fishery. He then made his way to Halifax, where he worked as a labourer for Brookfield Construction, Ltd. He had been employed in that position for three months when he was “called up” under the terms of the National Resources Mobilization Act (NRMA).

The NRMA authorized the creation of a mandatory national registry of young men suitable for military service. Once registered, individuals were randomly selected for a basic training program. Upon completion, the young men could be conscripted into “home defence” service, (i.e., in Canada only). It was common, however, for trainees to voluntarily enlist upon completing the program.

On August 31, 1942, Garfield reported to the NRMS Clearing Depot, Halifax. In mid-September, he was “re-allocated” to the Royal Canadian Artillery, (RCA) A/A [Anti-Aircraft]. He  reported to A23 Coastal and Anti-Aircraft Centre, Halifax, for training on September 19, 1942. Upon completing the two-month program, Garfield was assigned to the 24th Light Anti-Aircraft Battery, RCA, Sydney, on November 18.

The 24th Light A/A Battery was part of the 16th Coastal Brigade, a group of militia units responsible for the defence of strategic locations along the Maritime coast. As one of several gathering places for Allied vessels heading overseas, Sydney harbour played a vital role in the trans-Atlantic convoy system. Garfield spent four months with the unit before deciding to enlist for overseas service.

On March 29, 1943, Garfield formally joined the Canadian Active Service Force (CASF) at Halifax. The decision meant that he could be assigned to any active military unit—air force, artillery or infantry. Garfield spent the remainder of the year in Halifax. During that time, he received two weeks’ leave in late April and a five-day holiday leave in mid-December.
 
Shortly after returning to duty, Garfield was re-allocated to the Canadian Infantry Corps on January 12, 1944. The decision meant he would have to complete infantry training. Two days after the assignment change, Garfield was transferred to No 1 Transit Camp, Windsor, NS, where he remained for one month. In mid-February, he reported to No. 60 Canadian Infantry (Basic) Training Centre, Yarmouth, for the first component of training.

In early April, 1944, Garfield moved on to A14 (Advanced) Infantry Training Centre, Aldershot, NS, for the final phase of instruction. While there, he was briefly hospitalized for an unidentified illness in late May. Upon completing training, he was granted six days’ pre-embarkation leave on July 8. One week after returning to duty, he departed for overseas.

Garfield arrived in the United Kingdom on July 27, 1944, and reported to No. 4 Canadian Infantry Reinforcement Unit (CIRU). His overseas arrival coincided with a significant increase in the demand for infantry reinforcements. Canadian units had been fighting in Italy for one year and a second combat zone developed in Normandy after the June 6, 1944 Allied invasion of German-occupied France.

Within a matter of weeks, Garfield would be assigned to one of the two theatres of war. The decision was temporarily postponed when he was admitted to No. 19 Canadian General Hospital on August 3. Once again, the nature of his illness is not revealed in his service file. He remained under medical care for two weeks before returning to No. 4 CIRU.

On September 5, 1944, Garfield departed for France, and disembarked in Normandy the following day. He was immediately posted to No, 2 Canadian Base Reinforcement Group (CBRG) as an “unposted reinforcement.” Less than two weeks later, he was assigned to the Royal Winnipeg Rifles and joined the unit in the field on September 19, 1944.

The Royal Winnipeg Rifles trace their origin to the 90th Winnipeg Battalion of Rifles, a Canadian militia unit established in the city on November 9, 1833. The unit saw its first combat service during the 1885 North-West Rebellion, where its Métis opponents described the soldiers as “little black devils,” the colour their dark green uniforms when viewed from a distance. The battalion adopted the moniker, along with a crest displaying the silhouette of a black devil holding a trident in one hand and a chalice in the other.

During the First World War, the 90th recruited the 8th Battalion (90th Winnipeg Rifles), which served with the 1st Canadian Division in Belgium and northern France. During the inter-war years, the unit underwent a series of name changes before receiving the title of “Royal Winnipeg Rifles” (RWR) on June 3, 1935.

Following the outbreak of the Second World War, the Winnipeg unit recruited a battalion for overseas service in July 1940. The volunteers trained at Camp Shilo, MB, for several weeks before relocating to Camp Debert, NS. In September 1940, The RWR arrived in the United Kingdom as part of the 3rd Canadian Infantry Division’s 7th Brigade. The Winnipeg unit would eventually enter combat alongside the Regina Rifle Regiment and the Canadian Scottish Regiment (Princess Mary’s).

The RWR set foot in Normandy, France, on June 6, 1944, during the first wave of D-Day landings. Its soldiers participated in the attack on Caen in early July and the fierce fighting that occurred south of the city after its fall. During the month of August, Canadian units participated in two major operations along the Caen - Falaise road as part of a plan to encircle German forces in Normandy.

While partially successful, a significant portion of enemy units were able to escape through the “Falaise gap” before it was completely closed in mid-August. Allied forces then pursued retreating German units northward toward the Seine River. Before month’s end, Canadian units received orders to clear enemy forces from the “Channel ports,” a collection of strategic locations along the French coast. After passing through the city of Rouen, the Canadians veered to the northwest, liberating the ports of Dunkirk and Le Tréport.

The units continued northward toward the area of Boulogne and Calais, where a group of coastal artillery batteries posed a major threat to Allied shipping in the English Channel. On September 6, the 7th Canadian Infantry Brigade occupied an area of high ground seven miles southwest of Calais, cutting off communication with Boulogne. Having isolated the two ports, the attack on Boulogne, given the code name “Operation Well-hit,” commenced on September 17, and involved units from the 3rd Canadian Infantry Division’s 8th and 9th Brigades.

Meanwhile, the 7th Brigade prepared for an assault on Calais, which presented several unique challenges. A network of canals cut through the landward approaches to the fortified city, while marshy ground and “inundated [flooded] areas” presented obstacles to the south and east. A road and rail line eastward to Gravelines ran along a solitary, well-fortified ridge.

Calais itself still contained most of its historic fortifications. A bastioned wall and moat surrounded much of the city. Its modern defences, however, all faced toward the sea. A network of batteries, pillboxes, machine gun positions and concrete shelters for rail car-mounted artillery guns stretched along the coastline. Minefields and an anti-tank ditch connecting the flooded areas to the sea protected the coastal installations, while infantry positions and minefields, supported by field, anti-aircraft and anti-tank guns, guarded the land approaches to the south and east.

Fewer than 10,000 German personnel manned the city’s defences, one-third of whom were infantrymen. The remainder operated the coastal guns and port facilities. The majority of personnel were older men and their morale was low, characteristics that favoured the attacking forces.

The Allied plan called for a preliminary aerial and artillery bombardment of German positions, followed by a heavily-supported infantry attack. A smoke screen approximately 3,000 meters wide would be deployed to shield Allied artillery positions from observation at the Cape Gris Nez batteries, which still remained under German control.

The attack was to unfold in two stages. The initial phase focused on Cape Griz Nez and the western approaches to Calais. Once these areas were secured, Canadian units would concentrate on the city itself, simultaneously attacking the well-fortified location from the west, south and east.

Units from the 7th and 8th Brigades were selected to conduct the first stage of the operation, with support from the 2nd Canadian Armoured Brigade’s tanks. The 7th Brigade was to “capture or destroy” the garrisons at Belle Vue, Coquelles and Calais itself, while the 8th Brigade secured enemy positions at Escalles, near Cape Blanc Nez, and Noires Mottes on the city’s western flank.

In the midst of these preparations, Private Garfield James Munroe joined the Winnipeg Rifles’ ranks on September 20. It appears that he arrived in the same reinforcement draft that included Rifleman Charles Henry “Charlie” Snyder, Halfway Cove, who was assigned to the Regina Rifle Regiment on the same day. The two inexperienced Guysborough County men had little time to adjust to the front lines, as the attack on Calais, dubbed “Operation Undergo,” was imminent. Both would see combat for the first time during its initial stage.

While infantry units were ready to proceed, poor weather delayed the aerial bombardment until the afternoon of September 24, when approximately 200 Allied aircraft struck targets in the Calais area. A second air raid took place around 0815 hours September 25. While the bombing damaged German defences and further weakened morale, it was not a decisive blow.

Source: "The Victory Campaign" by C. P. Stacey

At 1015 hours September 25, soldiers from two 3rd Brigade units—the Regina Rifles and Winnipeg Rifles—moved forward toward their objectives. While the Reginas moved forward toward Coquelles, with support from the British 6th Armoured Regiment, the “Little Black Devils” advanced toward neighbouring Vieux Coquelles. Simultaneously, 8th Brigade units attacked Cape Gris Nez on the 3rd Brigade’s left flank.

The RWR encountered stiff resistance but succeeded in driving enemy forces from their bomb-proof shelters. Moving on toward Calais, they encountered mines, snipers and pockets of resistance as German artillery targeted their advance. Significant fighting occurred at Coquelles, where personnel engaged enemy soldiers in house to house combat. Despite the obstacles, the unit secured its objective by day’s end.

The Regina Rifle Regiment on the RWR’s left flank also gained its objective by nightfall. The 7th Brigade attack thus secured the area directly west of Calais. On its left flank, 8th Brigade units cleared enemy forces from the Cape Blanc Nez battery. The combined victories set the stage for a final assault on the city of Calais itself, scheduled to commence within 48 hours.

On the morning of September 26, Allied bombers conducted a raid on German defensive positions in and around Calais. 7th Brigade units crept forward throughout the day and were within striking distance of the city’s defences by nightfall.

The second phase of the operation was scheduled for September 27. The 7th Brigade’s Royal Winnipeg Rifles were to advance through Coquelles, cross a small flooded area and secure Fort Nieulay, west of the city. On their right flank, the Regina Rifle Regiment was to follow a rail line leading into the city, cross a flooded area adjacent to the tracks by boat and then advance toward a “Factory Area” along the city’s southern outskirts.

Meanwhile, the 1st Canadian Scottish Regiment, the 7th Brigade’s third unit, would capture Fort Lapin on the coast and prepare to advance toward the Citadel, the city’s main fortification. Once all objectives were secured, the three units would launch a final attack on the city itself.

Before the infantry attack commenced, Canadian units temporarily withdrew a short distance to allow Allied heavy bombers to conduct another raid on German defensive positions. Once the aircraft had completed their mission, the infantry attack commenced. The RWR made slow but steady progress toward Fort Nieulay in the face of strong resistance. The objective was secured only after further aerial bombing and assistance from regular and flame-throwing tanks.

Simultaneously, the Reginas managed to cross the flooded land and reach the Factory Area. That evening, the 1st Canadian Scottish secured Fort Lapin and prepared to launch an attack on the city’s coastal defences.

The advance continued on September 28, the Regina Rifles pushing northward through the Factory Area. Two 1st Canadian Scottish Companies managed to cross a canal on the city’s western edge but enemy fire forced the soldiers to the ground, preventing them from retreating. The soldiers were forced to take cover there until the city’s capture brought fighting to an end.

By this time, German forces inside the city found themselves in a desperate situation. Morale was low and increasing numbers of men were surrendering or abandoning their positions. On the evening of September 28, Lieutenant-Colonel Ludwig Schroeder, Commander of the German garrison, contacted Allied command, suggesting that Calais should be declared an “open city” and that all combat cease.

Allied leadership flatly rejected the suggestion, but subsequent discussions led to an agreement for a 24-hour truce, to commence at mid-day September 29. the purpose was to allow approximately 20,000 French civilians trapped in the city to leave. As residents streamed out of Calais, Allied commanders prepared for a final assault, with air support if necessary.

When the ceasefire expired at noon September 30, Canadian units immediately resumed the attack and German resistance quickly collapsed. At 2100 hours, Lt.-Col. Schroeder officially surrendered to 7th Brigade units and ordered his men to lay down their arms. By 0900 hours October 1, Calais was firmly in Canadian hands.

A total of approximately 7,500 German prisoners were taken during the Calais operation, while attacking forces reported a surprisingly light total of 300 casualties. The 7th Brigade bore the brunt of the losses, reporting 190 casualties. The Royal Winnipeg Rifles suffered 77 casualties, while the Regina Rifles incurred a total of 71 men killed or wounded.

There were 21 fatalities among the RWR’s casualties. The worst losses occurred on the first day of each stage. Nine soldiers died on September 25, while 10 were killed on September 27. Private Garfield James Munroe was among the men killed in action on September 27, 1944. Nine days later, Daniel Munroe received a telegram from Canadian military authorities. informing him of Garfield’s death.

On October 13, Garfield’s remains were interred in Hardinghen Canadian Military Cemetery, a temporary graveyard located 20 kilometers south of Calais. He was re-interred in Calais Canadian Military Cemetery, Saint-Inglevert, France, on August 6, 1945.

Garfield’s father Daniel died in Canso on September 9, 1962, and was interred in St. Agnes Cemetery, Little Dover. Daniel’s wife Annie passed away in Hazel Hill on January 13, 1984, and was laid to rest beside her husband.

Garfield’s older brother Alonzo Vincent “Lonnie” also enlisted for military service during the Second World War. He initially served with the Pictou Highlanders, a Nova Scotia militia unit, and later attested with the CASF. Lonnie was assigned to a Royal Canadian Army Service Corps unit that was attached to the 2nd Medium Regiment, Royal Canadian Artillery.

Lance Corporal Alonzo Vincent "Lonnie" Munroe

Lonnie’s RCASC unit served with 1st Canadian Army’s No. 1 Army Group, RCA, in Italy from July 1943 to early 1945, at which time the group relocated to the Netherlands and Germany for the final months of the war. During his time in uniform, Lonnie was promoted to the rank of Lance Corporal and was Mentioned in Dispatches (MID) “in recognition of gallant and distinguished services” in the field.

Upon returning to Canada, Lonnie married Florence Alice Cohoon, daughter of Cecil James Cohoon and Rose Anne Eustace, at Canso on January 7, 1947. The couple initially settled in Sydney, but later moved to Toronto, ON, where Lonnie worked as a barber. Lonnie and Rose Anne raised a family of four children. Later in life, they returned to Canso, where Lonnie passed away on June 21, 1993. He was laid to rest in Star of the Sea Roman Catholic Cemetery, Canso.

Special thanks to Jackie, Munroe, Woodstock, ON, for reviewing the Munroe family information and providing a picture of her father, Lance Corporal Alonzo Vincent Munroe.

No comments:

Post a Comment