Sergeant William John Anderson "Bill" Dunning—Accidentally Killed February 15, 1945

 William John Anderson “Bill” Dunning was born in Heart’s Content, Newfoundland, on November 19, 1915, to John Carmichael and Jessie Emma (Cook) Dunning. Bill’s father John was a native Kilbarchan, Renfrewshire, Scotland, born on September 1, 1882, the son of William Dunning and Janet Carmichael.

Sergeant William John Anderson "Bill" Dunning

John C. Dunning arrived in Newfoundland in 1901 to work as a telegraphist at the Anglo-American Telegraph Company’s Heart’s Content cable station. The steam vessel Great Eastern had brought the first successful trans-Atlantic cable ashore in the small Newfoundland community on July 27, 1866.

The Anglo-American Telegraph Company established a cable operation in Heart’s Content that expanded to include more than 200 telegraphists and support staff. In 1912, Western Union Telegraph Company acquired the Anglo-American Telegraph Company and integrated its assets into its communication network.

Bill’s mother, Jessie Emma Cook, was born in Heart’s Content on January 14, 1887, the daughter of John and Emma Amelia Cook. John was employed as a telegraphist at the local cable station. His presence there likely explains how his daughter Jessie and John Dunning made one another’s acquaintance. The couple married in Heart’s Content on September 20, 1905.

By the time of their marriage, John had relocated to the Commercial Cable Company’s telegraph station in Hazel Hill, Guysborough County. The newlyweds took up residence in the community, where their first child, Jean Carmichael, was born on June 20, 1906. A second daughter, Mary Elizabeth, joined the family on July 30, 1910. For unknown reasons, Jessie was in Heart’s Content, Newfoundland, at the time of Bill’s November 1915 birth. John and Jessie’s youngest child, Margaret, was born in Hazel Hill on July 30, 1918.

Bill Dunning commenced public school in Hazel Hill in 1920 and completed high school in nearby Canso in the spring of 1934. The following year, he obtained a position as a salesman with Mutual Life Assurance Company, a general insurance agency. He also did “general construction and repair work” at the Commercial Cable Company station. A later letter in Bill’s military service file, written by a former Superintendent, provided this assessment of his work there:

“I engaged [Bill] on several occasions to assist the Chief Engineer and found him upright, honest and a willing worker. He learned quite a lot about running gas engines under expert tuition. As he is mechanically inclined I have no hesitation in recommending him for a position where a knowledge of mechanics is required.”

By September 1939, Bill’s mechanical interests prompted him to relocate to Halifax, NS, where he landed a job “servicing… cars” at Hubley’s Imperial Service Station, Spring Garden Road. During the winter of 1939-40, he completed “short courses on Diesel Engines, Welding, machine tool operations and electricity” at Nova Scotia Technical College (NSTC), Halifax.

On February 5, 1940, Bill applied for admission to the Royal Canadian Air Force (RCAF). He described himself as “mechanically inclined. Have had practical experience in car mechanics” and specifically requested consideration for “ground duties.” Several recommendations, including the former Commercial Cable Company Superintendent’s letter, accompanied his application. Correspondence from one of his NSTC professors described Bill as “industrious and a good worker, with a great keenness for machinery.”

Following an April 25, 1940, interview, an RCAF recruitment officer described Bill as “keen…[and] intelligent,” and recommended that he be accepted for “Machinist or Armourer training.” A second comment stated that he might make a suitable Instructor at a later date and recommended him for acceptance as a “Standard Trainee.”

On July 22, 1940, Bill Dunning attested with the RCAF at Halifax, NS, commencing service with the rank of Aircraftman Class 2 (AC2). While awaiting training, he was assigned to “temporary duty” at RCAF Station Dartmouth, NS, on August 16. One month later, he reported to Military District No. 1 Toronto. On September 28, Bill was posted to the Canadian Air Armament School (CAAS), Trenton, ON, where he commenced Armourer training three days later.

RCAF “Armourers” were responsible for the overall maintenance and repair of aircraft, including armaments, weapons systems and communication equipment. In a general sense, their primary duty was to ensure that planes under their supervision were “mission ready,” whatever their assigned task.

Bill spent almost three months at CAAS. An assessment document in his service file, dated December  23, 1940, states that he achieved an overall grade of 66.5 % in the School’s No. 22 Armourers Course, placing 23rd in a class of 42 participants. A comment on the evaluation form noted, “He has worked well, but [is] especially good at workshops. He will be a good Flight Armourer.”

On December 26, 1940, Bill was transferred to No. 9 Standard Flight Training School, Summerside, PEI, for further training. The facility officially opened the following month. Following the outbreak of widespread German U-boat activity in the North Atlantic in 1941, the base transitioned to a “General Reconnaissance School,” training personnel for coastal air patrols.

Bill worked with ground crew at the Summerside base for seven months. During that time, he advanced to the rank of Leading Aircraftman (LAC) on April 1, 1941. In early August 1941, he was transferred to No. 10 Air Observer School, Chatham, NB. The facility had also recently commenced operation, training Air Navigators aboard Avro Anson aircraft.

Within a month of his arrival in Chatham, Bill was promoted to the rank of Acting Corporal, the first indication that his performance had impressed his supervisors. A note in his file provided this assessment: “His armour training and experience warrants promotion…. This airman [is] responsible and diligent to a marked degree. Deportment good.”

During Bill’s time in New Brunswick, he continued to progress through the non-commissioned ranks . On November 14, 1941, he was recommended for advancement to the rank of Temporary Sergeant: “This NCO is hard-working, steady, and deserving of promotion…. Recommended for training as a Senior Armament Instructor.” A second recommendation, dated April 30, 1942, stated: “This NCO takes a great deal of interest in his work, assumes responsibility easily, and is deserving of promotion.” The following day, Bill was awarded the rank of Temporary Sergeant.

On July 7, 1942, Bill was posted to No. 2 Operational Training Unit (OTU), Pennfield Ridge, NB. Located in southwestern New Brunswick, close to the village of St. George, the site included the British Commonwealth Air Training Plan’s standard three runways, laid out in triangular formation.

The variety of aircraft operating out of Pennfield Ridge provided an excellent training environment for Armourers. At various times, No. 2 OTU personnel flew the British single-engine Westland Lysander, the twin-engine Avro Anson and Bristol Bolingbroke. Several American models—the twin-engine Lockheed Ventura and Douglas Dakota, and the four-engine B-24 Liberator—were also part of its fleet at various times.

On August 10, 1942, Bill was transferred to RCAF Station Sydney, NS. Located on the site of the present-day airport, the base was established in 1937 and became No. 8 (Bomber Reconnaissance) Squadron’s initial station after the outbreak of war. Its personnel operated Bristol Bolingbroke two-engine aircraft while conducting anti-submarine duty off the eastern Canadian coast.

In December 1941, No. 8 Squadron relocated to RCAF Station Sea Island, near Vancouver, BC, where it served with RCAF Western Air Command for the duration of the war. No. 116 (Bomber Reconnaissance) Squadron took its place, conducting anti-submarine patrols out of Dartmouth and Sydney, NS, as well as Gander, Newfoundland. No. 116’s pilots operated Consolidated PBY Catalina and Canadian-built Canso aircraft on their assignments. The Catalina was a “flying boat,” while the Canso was equipped with a retractable wheeled undercarriage, allowing it to land on both water and land.

Three months after arriving in Sydney, Bill underwent an assessment. He received “excellent” ratings in appearance and bearing, energy and persistence, accuracy and reliability, and loyalty, and “very good” ratings in mental alertness, power of expression, self-confidence, interest in station activities, initiative, leadership, service knowledge, and administrative ability. His “trade proficiency” rating was “superior.”

On February 23, 1943, Bill “proceeded on temporary duty” to Ben Eoin, NS, the first of seven such assignments over the next 15 months. Each time, he remained there for approximately four weeks before returning to RCAF Sydney. According to family sources, the RCAF had deployed targets on the Bras d’Or Lakes for bomb training and personnel were dispatched to Ben Eoin to maintain the targets.

The spring of 1943 brought another significant event in Bill’s life. On April 27, 1943, he officially requested permission to marry Eva Clara Fulton. Born in Truro, NS, on April 19, 1912, Eva was the daughter of Scott and Carrie (Knight) Fulton, Bass River, NS. After graduating from Dalhousie University, she pursued a career in education.

Sergeant Bill and Eva (Fulton) Dunning, May 10, 1943

Around 1938, Eva had arrived in Canso, where she accepted a teaching position in the local public school. Upon completing her first term of service, “she was called back to accept the position of Principal,” a capacity in which she served for three years. During her time in the community, she met Bill and their relationship progressed to a marriage proposal.

On May 10, 1943, Bill and Eva were married in a ceremony that took place in Truro, NS. Following the ceremony, Eva replaced Bill’s father John as his next of kin and established residence in Hazel Hill, while Bill returned to duty at RCAF Sydney in late May. During the summer months, Eva relocated to Sydney, where she and Bill cleaned out a chicken coop along the shoreline near Ben Eoin as a temporary residence during Bill’s tours there. The couple’s first and only child, John Scott Dunning, was born in Truro on February 17, 1944.

Sgt. Bill and Eva Dunning with son John

During the month of July 1944, Bill spent two weeks in Summerside, PEI, and a third week in Moncton, NB, before returning to Sydney. On August 3, 1944, he was officially posted to No. 116 Squadron, Sydney, with the rank of Sergeant. Bill’s duties involved directing and overseeing ground crew as they maintained the Squadron’s fleet of Canso aircraft. The base contained four large hangars, each housing four of the large planes.

With the exception of a brief hospitalization in mid-January 1945, Bill served in Sydney without incident for the next six and a half months. The morning of February 15, 1945, began quietly. As pay parade was scheduled for personnel, most were standing in line to collect their wages before reporting for duty. As a result, only an estimated 30 men were on duty in Hangar No. 4.

Each Canso in the hangar was outfitted with four bomb racks, two under each wing. Each rack held a depth charge for use during anti-submarine patrols. Shortly after 0900 hours, one of the mechanisms holding a depth charge in place approximately three metres above the floor inexplicably released. The bomb struck the concrete, bounced and detonated, creating a fire that quickly spread to the remaining three aircraft.

Within minutes, the entire structure was engulfed in flames. Gasoline from ruptured fuel tanks flowed across the floor and quickly ignited, spreading the fire to storage facilities. Small explosions continued as the fire reached rounds of gun cartridges in an ammunition room. While the Station’s fire crew quickly arrived on the scene, the force of the initial explosion completely destroyed the hangar and the resulting fire was beyond control.

The majority of the personnel in the hangar miraculously managed to escape from the burning structure. The initial explosion and fire, however, resulted in four fatalities—LAC Herbert William Collins, Belleville, ON; LAC Herbert Frederick Hicks, Buckingham, QC; LAC Roy Richard Whiteside, London, ON; and Sergeant William John Anderson Dunning, Hazel Hill, NS.

Bill’s remains were transported to Hazel Hill, where he was interred in All Saints Cemetery. He was 29 years old at the time of his death. Bill’s father John passed away at the family’s Fox Island Main cottage on October 31, 1948, and was buried near his son’s final resting place. John’s widow Jessie passed away on January 26, 1968, and was laid to rest beside him.

After her husband’s death, Eva and her son John remained in Canso, where she taught school for several years before accepting a teaching/principal position in Bass River. In 1961, Eva left the classroom to become Supervisor of Schools for Colchester-East Hants, a position she held until her 1972 retirement. After leaving Canso, Eva maintained a connection to the area, purchasing a cottage beside the Dunning summer residence in Fox Island Main. She and her son John spent their summers there until the structure was destroyed in a fire.

In 1969, Eva married widower David Keith Corbett, another Bass River native. She actively supported several charitable organizations and became a devoted grandmother to three grandchildren and their families. In 2004, Eva and Keith moved to Parkland Estates Assisted Living Facility, Truro. Eva passed away in Colchester Regional Hospital, Truro, on December 19, 2004, and was laid to rest in the United Baptist Church Cemetery, Bass River, Colchester County, NS.

A special thank you to John Dunning, Bass River, son of Sgt. Bill and Eva (Fulton) Dunning, for contributing photographs and valuable family information for this blog post.